Patent Wars: Microsoft Takes Motorola To EU

austin123
added Feb 22, 2012 10:50:47 AM
Share This:

Microsoft on Wednesday filed a complaint with the European Commission against Google's Motorola Mobility in the latest salvo in an increasingly bitter patent war between technology giants.

Apple, which is embroiled in a multi-continent patent fight with South Korea's Samsung, lodged a similar complaint against Motorola Mobility with European competition regulators last week.

Both Microsoft and Apple accuse Motorola Mobility, which is being acquired by Google for $12.5 billion, of unfairly using its patent portfolio to try to block competing products.

At issue are what are known as standard essential patents. SEPs are patents that have been identified by technology companies as necessary to allow them to build compatible products.

Motorola Mobility is failing to live up to an industry pledge to license SEPs to rivals on fair, reasonable and nondiscriminatory terms, according to Microsoft and Apple.

"Motorola is attempting to block sales of Windows PCs, our Xbox game console and other products," Microsoft deputy general counsel Dave Heiner said, explaining the software giant's decision to file a complaint with the EC.

"Motorola is demanding that Microsoft take its products off the market, or else remove their standards-based ability to play video and connect wirelessly," Heiner said in a blog post.

"(Motorola Mobility) is on a path to use standard essential patents to kill video on the Web, and Google as its new owner doesn't seem to be willing to change course," he said.

US and European regulators gave the green light last week to Google's acquisition of Motorola Mobility.

Google, whose Android software is used by smartphone and tablet computer makers, acquired 17,000 patents with the purchase of the Illinois-based maker of mobile phones, tablet computers and television set-top boxes.

Announcing the acquisition in August, Google chief executive Larry Page said it will "enable us to better protect Android from anti-competitive threats from Microsoft, Apple and other companies."

The US Justice Department's antitrust division, in approving the Google-Motorola Mobility deal, said Google, Apple and Microsoft had made commitments concerning their SEP licensing policies.

"The division's concerns about the potential anticompetitive use of SEPs was lessened by the clear commitments by Apple and Microsoft to license SEPs on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory terms," it said.

Google's commitments, however, "were more ambiguous and do not provide the same direct confirmation of its SEP licensing policies," the department said.

Heiner said Motorola Mobility "has refused to make its patents available at anything remotely close to a reasonable price.

"For a $1,000 laptop, Motorola is demanding that Microsoft pay a royalty of $22.50 for its 50 patents on the video standard," he said, while a group of 29 companies was making 2,300 other patents available for just two cents.

"If every firm priced its standard essential patents like Motorola, the cost of the patents would be greater than all the other costs combined in making PCs, tablets, smartphones and other devices," Heiner said.

Microsoft was not using SEPs in an attempt to block smartphones or tablets running Android, Heiner said, and he appealed to Google to change course.

"For a company so publicly committed to protecting the Internet, one might expect them to join the growing consensus against using standard essential patents to block products," he said.

Patent analyst Florian Mueller said on his FOSS Patents blog he expected the EC to "make a determination on the launch of full-blown investigations within a few months."

Mueller adde
d that "if every owner of standard-essential patents behaved like Motorola, this industry would be in chaos, and grind to a halt.

"It's key that the owners of such patents act responsibly, and if some of them don't, antitrust intervention is needed," he said.

"I don't dispute any company's right to defend its intellectual property vigorously, but when standard-essential patents are involved, there must be clear limits."

Source: AFP
 
 
 Mark as Favorite

RELATED ON CARBONATED.TV

Google’s Motorola Phone Bid Likely To Survive Scrutiny By U.S....

Google Inc. (GOOG) may need to make concessions to win Justice Department approval of its planned acquisition of Motorola Mobility Holdings Inc., antitrust lawyers and analysts said.

 

Google Motorola Bid Approved In EU And US

US regulators have approved Google's $12.5bn (£7.9bn) bid for phone maker Motorola Mobility, hours after it won clearance from European authorities.

 

iPhone Passes Blackberry In US: ComScore

Apple’s iPhone has leapfrogged Research In Motion’s Blackberry to grab fourth-place among handset manufacturers in the United States, tracking firm comScore said Tuesday.

 

To comment you need to login or connect via:

LEAVE A COMMENT

480 characters remaining

 
 

Latest in Biz & Tech

Verizon Data Fans To Pay More In Service Or Phones

peter
Verizon Wireless plans to make its data-hungry customers pay a lot more, either in service fees or smartphone prices, as it tries to cut...

JPMorgan's Dimon Says Will Testify Before Congress

john
JPMorgan Chase & Co Chief Executive Jamie Dimon has agreed to testify before Congress over the bank's recent trading losses, which have...

Postal Service To Begin Closing Plants This Summer

Ricky
The nearly bankrupt U.S. Postal Service is moving forward with a multibillion-dollar cost-cutting plan that will close nearly 250 mail...

Strong Wal-Mart Profit Trumps Bribery Probe Concerns

Jackson
Wal-Mart Stores Inc's profit and sales surpassed expectations on Thursday as more people shopped at its established U.S. stores and spent...

Fitch Downgrades Greece, Cites Euro Exit Risk

ryan
Fitch ratings agency downgraded debt-crippled Greece deeper into junk territory on Thursday, warning of a probable Greek exit from the...
 
 

Carbonated Exclusive

A Layman’s Guide To Eurozone Crisis… What’s All The Havoc About?

 

Popular in Biz & Tech

 

Sand Flea Jumping Robot

 
 

Jon Stewart Argues With Siri Over Foxconn (VIDEO)

 
 

Motorola Xooms In On Tablet Market

 
 

Quantum Levitation Wipe Out Race Track (VIDEO)

 
 

Quantum Levitation Floating Disc Demonstration By Jim...

 
 

 

Inside Carbonated.TV

 

News & Politics

Activist Chen Guangcheng Says Passport Application Done

Afghan Attack: Seven Killed In Farah Compound Raid

John Edwards Was A 'Bad Husband,' But Not A Criminal, Lawyer Argues

Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s Wife Mary Kennedy Reportedly Hanged Herself

Entertainment

Adele's '21' Passes 9 Million Sales Mark In The US

65th Cannes Film Festival In Pictures

Britney Is Back - And So Are The Brickbats

Gender Row Marks Opening Of Cannes Film Festival

WOW

Limbless Frenchman Begins Epic World Swim

Energetic Dogs Play Ring Around The Rosy VIDEO

Max The Dog Tries To Get Through A Door With A Rake In His Mouth VIDEO

This Cat Loves Being Vacuumed! VIDEO

Sports

Saints’ Vilma Sues NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell Over Bounty Statements

Brett Lawrie Drops Appeal Of 4-Game Suspension For Tossing Helmet That Hit Umpire

Connor Barth Signs Four-Year, $13.2M Deal With Bucs

Manny Pacquiao Denounces Anti-Gay Allegations

Biz & Tech

Warren Buffett To Buy 63 Newspapers From Media General For $142M

Postal Service To Begin Closing Plants This Summer

Facebook Co-Founder Turns $30,000 Savings To $3 Billion

Fitch Downgrades Greece, Cites Euro Exit Risk

Lifestyle

Dubai Underwater Hotel

Two Cups Of Coffee A Day Cuts Overall Risk Of Dying By 10 Percent, Research Shows

Refunds: Kardashian Curves Cost Shoe Company $40m

FDA Approves Home AIDS Tests

 


 
   
Login