Harvard's Historic Fox Club Revokes Membership For Female Students

Universities have come a long way from their exclusive origins, but recent developments at Harvard show that there's still room for growth.

A woman in winter clothes reading a tablet on a red chair by a fire pit surrounded by snow.

The Fox Club, one Harvard University's eight original all-male clubs, is back to being boys only after a short dabble in co-ed membership.

The Crimson, the university's newspaper, reports that the club's graduate board has revoked provisional membership for nine female students, placing the club itself in line for potential extinction as new sanctions for single-gender clubs will come into effect in fall 2017.

Harvard announced in May 2016 that students who joined single-gender groups unrecognized by the university would be unable to hold leadership positions in athletic teams and other official student groups, and that they would also no longer be able to receive college recommendation to prestigious fellowships like the Marshall and Rhodes scholarships.

The graduating class of 2021 will be the first group of students to be affected by these new rules, meaning that if single-gender clubs don't become co-ed quickly, their chance at new membership will take a severe hit. 

Amidst fierce campus debate over the existence of single-gender clubs, in October 2015 undergraduate members of the Fox Club invited nine female juniors and seniors to join, under some pressure from the university administration. The move caused deep rifts within the club, as there were members on the graduate board who opposed co-ed membership.

After much in-fighting, the graduate board members decided to allow the women to stay in the club, but as provisional members. It was a sexist compromise that some male club members protested by becoming provisional members themselves. The stalemate was a messy one, but with the administration's impending rules, there was hope for the female members and their allies.

However, on Monday, The Crimson reported that the Fox Club had revoked all provisional memberships and only invited the male members to reapply for full membership.

Although they have become a focal point of the campus battle for inclusive social clubs, the Fox Club is not alone, as The Crimson reports that only four of Harvard's 23 single-gender clubs have become co-ed at this point. Many have decided to hold off on change until they see how the sanctions play out in university politics, a sad indicator of how far society still has to go.

"A minority of the graduates inclusive of the graduate board are not in favor of women joining the club, so in this case. We have an example of a republic prevailing over a democracy," the Rev. Douglas W. Sears, who was a former graduate board president of the Fox Club, told NBC News.

He added that some people were just determined to be on the wrong side of history.

Universities were, in origin, exclusionary institutions designed as spaces for the elite. As the world made strides forward in gender, racial, and economic equality, the concept of universities shifted to become more inclusive, but old ways die hard.

John Thelin, a professor of higher education and public policy at the University of Kentucky, told reporters at NBC that the happenings at Harvard were similar to the turmoil in campus secret societies in the 1960s and 1970s, when many universities finally started to become co-ed. Harvard itself didn't become co-ed until the late 1970s, and it was no easy feat to establish a community with some gender equality.

In 1984, nine all-male clubs chose to sever official ties with Harvard rather than open their doors to female students.

"By extending their talent net beyond their traditional constituents, these institutions have become so much more talented and more vibrant," Thelin said of the shift from elitist institutions to more inclusive campuses. "With these kind of internal squabbles, I think there are some pretty serious values involved. I would say that the dinosaurs seemed to have come to life, maybe, in Cambridge."

Banner/Thumbnail Credit: Reuters

View Comments

Recommended For You